Licensed in California · NMLS #362311
EZOnline MortgageCalifornia Home Loans
(818) 305-6704Apply now
EZOnline MortgageCalifornia Home Loans
Apply
Home›Refinance›Forbearance vs Refinance
Refinance · If You're In Trouble

Forbearance vs refinance in California: which helps in a hardship?

When money gets tight, two very different tools often come up: forbearance and refinance. They solve different problems. This page explains both in plain language so you can understand which fits your situation. It is here to inform, not to sell.

The short version: forbearance is temporary relief, while a refinance is a permanent new loan. Let's compare them.

A relieved California homeowner relaxing after sorting out forbearance versus refinancing
Quick answer

Forbearance temporarily pauses or lowers your mortgage payments during a short-term hardship — but you still owe the paused amount later. Refinancing replaces your loan with a new one, which can lower your payment permanently, but you must qualify and usually have equity and steady income. Forbearance helps with a temporary problem; refinancing helps when you can qualify for better long-term terms.

What this means

These tools fit different situations:

Forbearance is for a temporary problem — a job loss, illness, or short gap in income. It buys you time, but the paused payments must be handled later.
Refinancing is for when you can qualify for a better loan — it lowers your payment going forward, but it is not designed as emergency relief.

If your income has dropped sharply, you may not qualify to refinance, which is exactly when forbearance or other hardship programs matter most. See Hardship - Mortgage Assistance.

Side-by-side comparison

FeatureForbearanceRefinance
Type of helpTemporaryPermanent
Do you still owe paused amounts?Yes, handled laterNo (it is a new loan)
Need to qualify?Less strictYes — credit, income, equity
Best forShort-term hardshipLong-term lower payment
Who to contactYour loan servicerA lender
Step by step

How forbearance works

1
You contact your loan servicer and explain your hardship.
2
They may pause or reduce your payments for a set time.
3
When forbearance ends, you arrange to handle the missed amount — through a repayment plan, a deferral to the end of the loan, or a modification.
4
It is meant to be temporary.
Step by step

How refinance works

1
You apply for a new loan to replace your current one.
2
You must qualify based on credit, income, and equity.
3
If approved, the new loan can lower your payment going forward.
4
It is a permanent change, with closing costs. See Refinance Check-Up (Is it worth it).

Which one fits?

Temporary hardship, can't pay right now? Forbearance or another hardship option is usually the path. See Hardship - Mortgage Assistance.
Stable income, want a lower payment long term? A refinance may help. See Lower My Payment.
Not sure? A free HUD-approved housing counselor can help you decide.

Requirements (at a glance)

OptionTypical requirement
ForbearanceA documented hardship; contact your servicer
RefinanceCredit, income, equity, and ability to repay

Benefits

Forbearance:
Quick, temporary relief.
Less strict than qualifying for a new loan.
Buys time during a rough patch.
Refinance:
Permanent lower payment (if you qualify).
Can improve your rate or term.
A long-term solution, not just a pause.

Things to watch (honest notes)

Forbearance is not forgiveness. You still owe the paused amount; plan for how it will be handled.
Refinancing needs qualifying. A drop in income may make it unavailable.
Credit impact. Both can have effects; ask before deciding.
Get free guidance. A HUD-approved counselor can help you choose.
This is not legal or financial advice. Confirm details with your servicer and a counselor.
Real-world California examples

What it looks like in practice

Example 1 — Temporary job loss in Sacramento.
Example 1 — Temporary job loss in Sacramento.

Maria loses her job for a few months. She requests forbearance to pause payments, then sets up a repayment plan once she is working again.

Example 2 — Stable income, high rate in San Diego.
Example 2 — Stable income, high rate in San Diego.

Marcus has steady income but a high rate. He refinances to lower his payment permanently — a better fit than forbearance for his situation. See Lower My Payment.

Example 3 — Refinance after recovery in San Jose.
Example 3 — Refinance after recovery in San Jose.

The Lee family used forbearance during a hardship. Later, once their income and credit recovered, they refinanced to lower their payment for the long term.

Examples are for learning only. Your options depend on your situation and eligibility.

Common mistakes

1Thinking forbearance erases the debt. You still owe the paused amount.
2Assuming you can always refinance. A drop in income may prevent it.
3Waiting too long to ask for help. Early action keeps more options open.
4Skipping free counseling. HUD-approved help is free and trustworthy.
5Ignoring credit effects. Ask how each option affects your credit.
6Not getting agreements in writing. Keep records of any plan.
Good questions

Frequently asked questions

Forbearance is temporary relief that pauses or lowers payments. A refinance is a new loan that can lower your payment permanently.

Next steps

Choose the path that fits

If your hardship is temporary, start with your servicer and consider forbearance or another hardship program. If you have steady income and want a lasting lower payment, explore refinancing. Whatever your situation, the most important step is to reach out early — to your servicer and a free HUD-approved counselor — so you can choose the right path with support.

Start Refinance Rates (818) 305-6704
Keep learning

This page is for education only. It is not legal, financial, or tax advice, and not a promise of approval, assistance, or any outcome. Confirm current options with your loan servicer and a HUD-approved housing counselor. Equal Housing Opportunity · NMLS #362311 · CA DRE #01871814.

CallStart my application